Jack-o'-Lantern Charcuterie Board: The Giant Pumpkin Board for 12 to 15

Quick Answer: To make a jack-o'-lantern charcuterie board, outline a 24 inch pumpkin with pretzel sticks on a round board, split it into six or seven curved ribs, and fill each rib with a different orange food: orange cheddar, Colby, Muenster or Gouda cubes, dried apricots and soppressata. Fill a triangle-eyed face with black olives and blackberries, add a stem of pretzel rods tied with twine, and ring it with black grapes, charcoal crackers, salami and clementines. It serves 12 to 15 and takes about 75 minutes.

This is the board people photograph before they eat. From across the room it reads as a giant carved pumpkin. Up close, it's cheddar, salami, apricots and grapes, and every bite can be picked up with your fingers. It's Board 23 in our book Impossible Boards, and it's one of the easiest in the book: difficulty 2 out of 5.

The trick: it's all in two details

The face is just black food. Outline two triangle eyes, a triangle nose and a jagged grin with pretzel sticks, then pack them with black olives and blackberries. Against all that orange, black reads instantly as a carved hole. You don't need to cut a single shape.

The ribs make it round. A flat circle of orange cheese looks like a plate of cheese. Divide the circle into curved bands that bow outward, like the ribs of a real pumpkin, and give each band a slightly different shade: bright orange cheddar, golden Colby, pale Muenster or Gouda, deep orange apricots and red soppressata. The change in color from band to band is what makes the pumpkin look three-dimensional.

What to put on it

For 12 to 15 guests, plan on about 3 pounds of cured meat and 4 pounds of cheese when the board is the main appetizer. That's in line with our how much charcuterie per person guide.

For the pumpkin

• Orange cheddar, the brightest rib and the biggest share of the cheese
• Colby or golden cheddar for a second shade of orange
• Muenster or Gouda for a pale rib
• Dried apricots, fanned in a rib of their own
• Soppressata, overlapping along one edge for a red rib (soppressata vs. salami if you're choosing)
• Thin pretzel sticks for the outline and the rib lines

For the face and stem

• Pitted black olives and blackberries
• Pretzel rods tied with kitchen twine
• A sprig of rosemary as the vine

For the outer ring

• Black grapes and charcoal or black-sesame crackers, for the dark frame
• Dry Spanish chorizo or hot salami, and pepperoni
• White cheddar and pepper jack cubes, for contrast
• Clementines, set in little groups like a pumpkin patch

How to build it

1. Outline the pumpkin. On a 36 to 40 inch round board, lay pretzel sticks in a slightly squat circle about 24 inches wide. Leave a ring of 6 to 8 inches around it.
2. Draw the ribs. Lay curved lines of pretzel sticks from top to bottom, bowing outward, to make six or seven bands.
3. Make the face. Outline the eyes, nose and a wide grin with two or three teeth, then pack them tightly with olives and blackberries so no board shows through.
4. Fill the ribs, one food per band, alternating light and dark shades of orange.
5. Add the stem and vine at the top: 10 to 12 pretzel rods tied in a bundle, with rosemary curled beside it.
6. Build the dark ring around the pumpkin: clusters of grapes, fans of crackers, folded chorizo and pepperoni, cheese cubes, and clementines in twos and threes.

Want the exact amounts for every item, the countdown from the day before and all eight steps on one printable? The full plan is below.

Get the full plan: The Giant Jack-o'-Lantern Board, a 7-page printable plan · $3. It has the shopping list with every amount for 12 to 15, the prep timeline, the layout map, the eight build steps, and easy, budget, gluten-free and spooky versions. It's Board 23 of the 25 in Impossible Boards, along with a dragon, a fondue volcano and a Thanksgiving turkey.

A smaller version for 6 to 8

The same design shrinks well. Use an 18 inch round board and make the pumpkin about 12 inches across with four or five ribs: orange cheddar, Colby, apricots and soppressata. Fill the face with olives only, use 5 or 6 pretzel rods for the stem, and keep the outer ring to grapes and crackers. You'll need roughly a third of the food.

Make it your way

• Easiest version: skip the ribs and fill the whole pumpkin with orange cheddar cubes. Just do the black face. It still reads as a jack-o'-lantern.
• On a budget: cheddar in every rib, pepperoni for all the meat, and clementine segments instead of dried apricots.
• Spookier: set it on black slate in a dim room with battery tea lights around the edge (never real flames on a food board), and add a "spider" made from a black olive with olive-slice legs.
• For kids: skip the hot salami and pepper jack, and let them fill the face. For toddlers, cut the grapes and olives into quarters. More ideas are in our charcuterie board for kids guide.
• Gluten-free: outline it with carrot sticks, make the stem from a bundle of celery, and use gluten-free crackers.

Make-ahead and food safety

The day before, cut all the cheese into cubes, slice the soppressata and store everything covered and separate in the fridge. About 2 hours before guests arrive, lay the outline, the ribs and the face. An hour before, fill everything in and build the outer ring. Add the stem and rosemary in the last 5 minutes.

Once it's out, keep it out for no more than 2 hours. For a long party, build the pumpkin and keep a container of refills cold. Our guide to making a board the night before has more on what can be done early.

Did you know? The first jack-o'-lanterns weren't pumpkins. In Ireland they were carved from turnips. Irish immigrants switched to the much bigger, easier-to-carve American pumpkin.

FAQ