Quick Answer: Most people: Formaticum Cheese Storage Bags (about $10 to $19 for 15). Cheapest that works: parchment plus foil, the winner in America's Test Kitchen's test. The gift: Cheese Grotto Mezzo ($150).
Our top picks
Plastic wrap traps moisture and cheese molds first; cheese needs a wrap that breathes but doesn't dry it out.
All 6 picks
Prices are retailer listings checked October 2026.
Best overall
Formaticum Cheese Storage Bags
- Count
- 15 bags
- Size
- 6.25 × 11 in
- Material
- Wax-coated paper, polyethylene
Why it's here: Two-ply paper lets cheese breathe while holding in some moisture, and each bag has a spot to write the cheese and date.
Watch out: Very soft cheeses get messy, and America's Test Kitchen found cheese paper added only a few days over parchment and foil.
Why we picked it (sources)
Food Network lists the 15-pack and its 4.5-star Amazon rating (Food Network); sizes from Formaticum (Formaticum).
Best for wedges
Formaticum Cheese Storage Sheets
- Count
- 15 sheets + 15 labels
- Size
- 11 × 14 in
- Best for
- Aged cheeses
Why it's here: Sheets wrap odd-shaped wedges snugly, and the labels seal and date them.
Watch out: Wrapping takes a little practice; the bags are faster.
Why we picked it (sources)
Di Bruno Bros. lists $8.99 for 15 sheets (Di Bruno Bros.); Formaticum recommends sheets for drier, aged cheeses (Formaticum).
Best cheap method
Parchment Paper and Aluminum Foil
- Brie and cheddar
- Like new after a month
- Goat cheese
- About a week
- Cost
- Rolls you already own
Why it's here: In America's Test Kitchen's six-week test, cheese wrapped in parchment or waxed paper and then loosely in foil kept best.
Watch out: Two steps every time, and nowhere to write a label.
Why we picked it (sources)
America's Test Kitchen's storage test (America’s Test Kitchen).
Best for blue cheese and charcuterie
Formaticum Reusable Cheese Storage Bags
- Count
- 10 bags
- Size
- 5 × 11 in
- Care
- Hand-wash, air-dry
Why it's here: Washable bags that Formaticum recommends for blue cheese, butter and leftover charcuterie.
Watch out: Smaller than the classic bags.
Why we picked it (sources)
Formaticum lists the size, count and best uses (Formaticum).
Best plastic-free
Formaticum Zero Cheese Storage Bags
- Count
- 10 bags
- Material
- Greaseproof paper, vegetable wax
- Best for
- Aged cheeses
Why it's here: The plastic-free version, made of greaseproof paper and vegetable-based wax.
Watch out: Best for firm, aged cheeses, not brie or fresh cheese.
Why we picked it (sources)
Formaticum lists the materials and best uses (Formaticum).
Best gift
Cheese Grotto Mezzo
- Holds
- Up to 2 lb
- Humidity
- Clay brick
- Use
- Fridge, or counter 1 to 5 days
Why it's here: A wood-and-glass box with a clay brick that holds humidity, so cheese stays fresh with no rewrapping.
Watch out: $150; the smaller Piatto holds 1 lb and the larger Fresco and Classico hold 6 and 8 lb.
Why we picked it (sources)
Cheese Grotto lists $150 and how it works (Cheese Grotto); model sizes (Cheese Grotto); press including CNET and Food & Wine (Cheese Grotto press).
How long cheese lasts, wrapped in the fridge
- Fresh (mozzarella, ricotta): 3 to 5 days, in its own liquid.
- Soft and bloomy (brie, Camembert, Taleggio): 1 to 2 weeks.
- Semi-soft (young Gouda, young Manchego): 2 to 3 weeks.
- Hard (aged Gouda, Comté, Gruyère): 3 to 4 weeks.
- Grating (Parmigiano-Reggiano, Pecorino Romano): 4 to 5 weeks.
Times are Formaticum's guidelines; trust your nose. More in how to store cheese and can you freeze cheese.
Cheese paper questions
Is cheese paper worth it?
For convenience, yes. In America's Test Kitchen's test, parchment plus loose foil worked as well; cheese paper added only a few days.
Can you reuse cheese paper?
Yes, for the same type of cheese. Wipe the inside with a damp paper towel and replace it once butterfat stains show.
Why not plastic wrap?
It traps moisture against the cheese. In America's Test Kitchen's test, plastic-wrapped cheese molded first.
Where in the fridge should cheese go?
The vegetable drawer, where it's colder and more humid than the door.
What's a good gift for a cheese lover?
A box of cheese storage bags is a good stocking stuffer; a Cheese Grotto is the splurge.
How we picked these, and sources
We used America's Test Kitchen's six-week storage test, Formaticum's product details and storage guidelines, and retailer listings. Cheese Grotto details are from the maker and its press page. Checked October 26, 2026.
- America's Test Kitchen: a good way to store cheese
- Food Network: the storage bags every cheese lover should have
- Formaticum: cheese storage FAQ
- Di Bruno Bros.: Cheese Storage Sheets
- Cheese Grotto: Mezzo
- Cheese Grotto: models and capacities
- Cheese Grotto: press and reviews
For tools, see the best cheese knife sets; for gifts, the best cheese-of-the-month clubs. Every guide is on our charcuterie buying guides page.
